We got into Belize City yesterday afternoon and were able to catch the last water taxi from town out to San Pedro, on Ambergris Caye. Supposedly Ambergris is the “upscale” caye; we likely won’t make it to Caulker, so I can’t make any comparisons, but San Pedro feels sufficiently backpacker-friendly to me. There are some fancy resorts further north on the island, so perhaps that’s why Ambergris has its hoity-toity reputation. Ambergris calls itself “La Isla Bonita” after the Madonna song; it is possible although not clear that the song was written about this island (other fun trivia I just learned from that Wikipedia link: La Isla Bonita was originally written for Michael Jackson, but he turned it down).
We don’t have much time here – only two nights, and then onward to the west tomorrow – but I don’t feel rushed. San Pedro is a tiny little rectangle of a town, probably only about four blocks across the skinny part of the Caye and maybe ten blocks long. And very relaxed. This is a place for snorkeling, diving, lounging by the shore, and drinking rum. While we’re officially in Central America, San Pedro has a distinctively Caribbean feel. We’ve been eating things like Jamaican-style jerk chicken and grilled grouper (we found a cheap tasty restaurant called El Patio. Like all restaurants around here, it has a thatched roof and a sandy floor). Most people speak English. We’ve also heard some Spanish and an English-derived Creole.
Most of the tourists here seem to be American. Many of them are young travelers like us, but we’ve also seen families with kids.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f85d7/f85d76914292c611f36d094cd144b1562da0cfc9" alt="IMG_8269"
Lauren on the water taxi from Belize City to Ambergris Caye
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4f207/4f2076d9f08ee03275802bf14f71d1e68c654add" alt="IMG_8271"
The Caye Caulker Water Taxi Terminal in Belize City
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/07228/07228057958d8eb53efcfb071e2f127e44a2f08e" alt="IMG_8280"
On the deck at our hotel in San Pedro